top of page

Matriarchal Astrology: Polarity Without the Gender Binary

3 days ago
6 min read

Matriarchal Astrology: Polarity without the Gender Binary

By Rev. Lilliana Blackstar


In my community there has been a lot of discussion about Matriarchy - specifically as a concept of egalitarian values that are non-patriarchal, inclusive, and humanitarian.  As these discussions and conversations unfold, we are asking ourselves how we can de-center the Patriarchy and de-colonize our thinking in the most prominent areas of our lives.


As an Astrologer, I wondered to myself how I could make my personal astrological practice more Matriarchal and Egalitarian.  I am not the first to hold discussions about decolonizing Astrology or re-thinking patriarchal systems that are seemingly baked in to the ancient practice of Astrology.  The leading voices I have heard working to deconstruct Astrology to be more inclusive and less Patriarchal are Alice Sparkly Cat (Postcolonial Astrology), Bear Ryver (Intersectional Astrology), Chani Nichols, Jessica Lanyadoo and Anna Joy. I am sure there are more, but these names give you a starting point if you want to explore.


I thought that I might begin a series of blog posts relating to foundational astrological concepts or archetypes and see how we can re-frame them to fit into a more inclusive matriarchal egalitarian collective society.  This is part one of that series, which I am hoping will be conversation starters to help us all explore these concepts in our daily lives, beyond Astrology.  I am not the expert with all the answers or the guru that must be followed unquestioningly - I’m just an Astrologer sharing ideas and hoping to spark conversations.


Polarity without the Gender Binary


The most obvious place to start is to look at the foundational Astrological concept of Polarity.  Historically, the 12 signs of the zodiac were divided into two groups, Masculine and Feminine.  Obviously the signs are not girls or boys and do not need to be divided by gender, but I do not think we need to throw away the entire concept of Polarity.  There are certainly deeper energetic lessons and mysteries within these labels, and we can understand that the ancient cultures who were recording the system of Astrology had reasons for making the distinction, even if they lacked more creative or nuanced language for the labels.  In modern times a lot of people have already switched to the words “Projective” and “Receptive” to describe these polarities, which helps avoid any overly gendered interpretation right out of the gate.  However, a lot of the descriptions and definitions of polarity still seem to include some level of binary gender essentialism, concluding that “Projective” is a naturally Masculine state and that “Receptive” is a naturally Feminine trait.  We all still have some work to do in deconstructing this ideal.


The polarities are historically also labeled as + / - (Positive and Negative). It is important to remember that this is not meant to express a moral judgement about good and bad. It is simply breaking the energy down into mathematical equations - one is adding and one is subtracting. However, over time within Patriarchal societies I think people began to conflate Masculine as Positive/Good and Feminine as Negative/Bad, and we will have to grapple with our own inherited biases as we reconsider the nature of the polarities.


In practice and in our daily realities, we know that any gender can be projective or receptive.  Regardless of gender identity, a person may be “Projective” at work and “Receptive” at home, or switch between a whole range of these throughout a day depending on circumstances and demands.  So what exactly is the Polarity of a sign supposed to help us understand about that sign?  Because Sagittarius is a Projective (Masculine) sign, but this doesn’t mean that a Sagittarius can’t be feminine or receptive or something beyond the binary.


Astrology Signs Polarity, Modality and Element
Astrology Signs with Polarity, Modality, and Element

What are the Polarities meant to describe?


Let’s break down the foundational concept of the Polarities to help us see beyond any gendered ideology.  


The polarities are one characteristic that is used to help you understand the nature of a sign.  The intention here is just to establish a foundation for seeing and describing the archetypal nature of the zodiac sign rather than to trap the sign within a strict or rigid box.  Yes, it is a binary system and we understand that the world is not black and white and there is so much of life that happens in the spectrum between extremes!  Yet so much of our world is understood through a binary lens.  When we talk of Day and Night we are not erasing the twilight hours.  When we speak of Hot and Cold or Light and Dark we are not pretending that nothing exists in between.  These are starting points to help us describe some foundational part of our experience to others.  Additionally, sometimes there can be overlap between these binaries that may seem counterintuitive.  It can be a Cold Night, or it can be a Hot Night.  Being Cold does not automatically mean that it has to be dark and Night Time.  The same is true with the Polarities of a Sign.  We are describing a basic foundational function of the sign itself, and from there we build more nuance and detail.  Sagittarius is a Projective sign.  It is also a Fire Sign, a Mutable Sign, ruled by the Planet Jupiter.  


So what are the labels of Projective and Receptive meant to tell us about a sign?


Projective (traditionally described as Masculine) energy might better be described as Generative.  It is energy that generates and projects itself onto the world around it.  Light is projective - it fills a room and overcomes the shadows.  Darkness is therefore a receptive energy because it only exists with the absence of light.  Darkness depends upon the light receding or being removed or covered in order to exist.  The Sun is Projective and Generative - the chemical reactions of burning gas are creating energy and light that projects outward from the Sun.  The Moon is receptive - it does not create its own light or heat, it receives the light of the sun and reflects it back.  Noise is projective and the Quiet is Receptive.


Primarily, the Polarities are meant to describe this foundational difference between the elements.  Fire and Air are Projective (Generative), while Water and Earth are Receptive (Regenerative).  Water will change based on the input it is receiving from the world around it - it will be hot or cold based on the presence of fire or light or the temperature of the air.  Water will change into the solid form of ice or the non-liquid form of steam based on what temperature inputs it is receiving from the world around it.  Earth recieves the water, the seeds, and the light and a regenerative or transformative process within the soil will cause those seeds to grow into fruit.  Wind, over time will shape the rocks and mountains, showing how the earth is receptive to the energy of air.  


There is nothing inherently gendered about any of these functions of the elements of Fire, Water, Air and Earth.  We only place any kind of gender upon the concept of Receptive and Projective because of some misplaced and outdated ideals of Patriarchy and Colonialism - but we can deconstruct these gendered concepts and return to the root concept of Polarity.  Remember, we don’t have to paint ourselves into a corner.  Water can be projective or generative just as much as it can be receptive and regenerative.  We are establishing foundational building blocks, not building prison walls.


Generative/Projective energy: Fire, Air, Heat, Light, Sound, Active, Outward, Extroverted, Fast, Yang, Expansive, Growing, Rigid, Hard, Speaking, Teaching.


Regenerative/Receptive energy: Water, Earth, Cold, Dark, Quiet, Rest, Inward, Introverted, Slow, Yin, Contracting, Receding, Flexible, Soft, Listening, Learning.


Ideally, when we understand the polarity of signs in our birth chart or transits, we can begin to break down a foundational part of the way energy is flowing, and we can then seek to balance that energy within ourselves and our surroundings.  When I look at the polarities of a chart, if I notice that there is an abundance of Projective energy and a lack of Receptive energy, I do not judge this as “good or bad” and I can avoid placing any kind of gendered concepts on this chart - but I can also see that this situation or person might benefit from more receptive and regenerative energy.  Everything is about balance.  Periods of activity need to be followed by periods of rest.  We need to cool down on a hot day, and we need to get warm on a cold day.  We need to find the balance between speaking and listening, and we need to sometimes be rigid and sometimes be flexible. 


Yes, there is a whole spectrum of existence in between the polartities of Generative and Regenerative.  This spectrum is where most of life actually exists.  The Polarities helps us identify the extremes, so that we can find our way back to the center.


Please share your thoughts!



Further reading for you:


Queer Astrology and Gender Identity


Postcolonial Astrology by Alice Sparkly Cat


Intersectional Astrology by Bear Ryver




Comments


©2026 by Hestia's Muse. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page